Dorothy [birth surname unproven]

Profile ID: G29_DOROTHY_WIFE_WILLIAM1560. Status: source_backed_secondary.

Death
before 31 May 1613

Biography

probate — Administration named Nicholas Phelps after Dorothy Phelps's death — 31 May 1613–31 May 1613 — Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England

Family relationships

This tree includes proposed relationships as well as established ones. Link confidence scores are research assessments, not calibrated statistical probabilities. A person in the directory may be a research candidate rather than an ancestor. Family roots describe historical context, not additional biological parents.

Family roots

Family roots: Name unresolved

Historical context, not a parent.

Tewkesbury, Gloucestershire, England

Published probate extracts name Dorothy as William Phelps’s widow on 28 September 1611 and report her death by 31 May 1613. They do not name her parents or give a birth surname. The proposed identification as Dorothy James must be compared with Henry James’s daughter in the Greswold pedigree.

The administration passed to William’s brother Nicholas during the minority of William’s son, also William. This places Dorothy in a specific household. The extracts establish a death interval, rather than an exact death in 1613; the original probate entries remain to be inspected.

meaning: Dorothy’s attested surname in the administration extract is the married name Phelps. James is a proposed natal surname from compiled pedigrees, not a name supplied by that extract.

origins: Tewkesbury is the home of her deceased husband in the probate record. The proposed James family belongs to Forfield in Worcestershire; no inspected record connects Dorothy Phelps’s childhood or parents to that place.

associations: The published 1619 visitation identifies Dorothy, daughter and coheiress of Henry James of Forfield, as Henry Greswold’s wife. This gives the proposed James ancestry a specific competing family context.

Henry James’s daughter in the Greswold pedigree — 1619 visitation; edition published 1877 — Forfield, Worcestershire; Greswold family pedigree — The pedigree pairs Henry Greswold with Dorothy, daughter and coheiress of Henry James of Forfield. It shows their sons Humphrey, William, George and Richard. — This is a concrete comparison for the claim that William Phelps’s wife was Henry James’s daughter. The proposed father and daughter match the names in the visitation, but the husband differs. — Dorothy Phelps could have been another Dorothy James, or the same woman through successive marriages. A further possibility is that later compilers transferred the Greswold wife’s parentage to the Phelps wife. — The inspected pedigree directly supports the Greswold marriage. No inspected record supports a second marriage linking that woman to Phelps, or identifies a different Dorothy James as William’s wife. Conflation is presently the better-supported explanation of the specific parentage claim, while Dorothy Phelps’s own birth family remains unresolved.

Sources: Phelps Family of America (1899): William Phelps and Dorothy, Tewkesbury register copies; Visitation of Warwickshire, 1619, edited John Fetherston (1877), p62: Greswold pedigree; Compiled Dorothy Phelps profile assigning Henry James and Bridget Littleton as parents

Sources

Sources: Phelps Family of America (1899): William Phelps and Dorothy, Tewkesbury register copies

Research notes

The 1899 book identifies Dorothy as William Phelps's wife and transcribes a 31 May 1613 administration stating that she had died, leaving William's goods still unadministered.

Her birth surname, dates before that point, and parentage remain unproven.

probate: status source_backed_secondary; confidence 0.82.

The book transcribes the administration. It establishes death by the stated date but not an exact death date.

Child: Thomas Phelps — The book places Thomas baptised 24 Jun 1590 in William and Dorothy's household, but the baptism line itself does not name his mother. This maternal edge is therefore plausible rather than direct. 15 September 2026: Printed p.20 gives 24 January 1590 in the parchment-copy transcription, while p.71 gives 24 June 1590 in the household summary. Both identify William as father. January also requires an Old Style year check against the register. No exact birth is established. Existing grade retained; original register comparison remains desirable.

Child: Mary Phelps, baptised 1587 — The book places Mary baptised in 1587 in William and Dorothy Phelps's household. The original entry has not yet been inspected.

Child: Mary Phelps, baptised 1588 — The book places Mary baptised in 1588 in William and Dorothy Phelps's household. The original entry has not yet been inspected.

Child: Dorothy Phelps — The book places Dorothy baptised in 1595 in William and Dorothy Phelps's household. The original entry has not yet been inspected.

Child: William Phelps of Tewkesbury (baptised 1599) — The book places William baptised in 1599 in William and Dorothy Phelps's household. The original entry has not yet been inspected.

Child: James Phelps — The book places James baptised in 1601 in William and Dorothy Phelps's household. The original entry has not yet been inspected. 15 September 2026: Printed p.20 gives 14 February 1601 in the paper-copy transcription, while p.72 gives 14 July 1601 in the household summary. Both identify William as father. February requires an Old Style year check. These are conflicting baptism claims, not exact birth dates. Existing grade retained; original register comparison remains desirable.

Child: Elizabeth Phelps — The book prints Elizabeth's 9 May 1603 baptism as daughter of William Phelps and Dorothy his wife.

Child: George Phelps — The book calls George, born about 1606, a son of William and Dorothy Phelps but acknowledges that his baptism is absent from the record. 15 September 2026 review: The asserted George son is absent from the book's baptism transcript and belongs to the older New England family reconstruction. The book's association of the Tewkesbury family with the Windsor immigrant is undermined by later Crewkerne research. This does not identify George's actual parents; retain only as a weak uncorroborated hypothesis.

Partner: William Phelps — The 1603 Elizabeth baptism provides direct household evidence for William and Dorothy as a couple, through a published transcription.