Profile ID: C_GANTRELL_SUSAN_WINTERBORNE_1585. Status: compiled_parish_reconstruction.
reported life span — This profile reports a birth 18 Aug 1585 in Winterborne Stickland, Dorset, England. — 18 Aug 1585 — Winterborne Stickland, Dorset, England
Sources: Winterborne Butt-Gantrell family: parish-register transcriptions; Winterborne Houghton parish-register transcription: Robert Butt baptized 17 September 1616; Dorset Online Parish Clerk: Winterborne Houghton parish records and archival holdings
record context — Susan’s reported 1585 baptism and 1607 marriage place her in the small Winterborne Houghton–Winterborne Stickland area of Dorset. The original parish registers survive, but the current evidence is a published transcription; an original entry would be needed to settle the locality variation and to strengthen the vital details. — 1585–1607 — Winterborne Houghton and Winterborne Stickland, Dorset, England
Sources: Winterborne Butt-Gantrell family: parish-register transcriptions; Dorset Online Parish Clerk: Winterborne Houghton parish records and archival holdings
This tree includes proposed relationships as well as established ones. Link confidence scores are research assessments, not calibrated statistical probabilities. A person in the directory may be a research candidate rather than an ancestor. Family roots describe historical context, not additional biological parents.
Sources: Winterborne Butt-Gantrell family: parish-register transcriptions; Winterborne Houghton parish-register transcription: Robert Butt baptized 17 September 1616; Dorset Hearth Tax Assessment, Michaelmas 1664: Robert Butt of Hargrove tithing; Nell Marion Nugent, Cavaliers and Pioneers, volume 1: Robert Bott/Butt patents of 1656 and 1665; Dorset OPC: Winterborne Whitechurch parish-register transcription, Robert Butt and Grace Dennes, 1 August 1678; Antony Broad parish transcription: Robert Butt son of Symon, baptized 12 April 1647
Sources: Winterborne Butt-Gantrell family: parish-register transcriptions
Sources: Winterborne Butt-Gantrell family: parish-register transcriptions
Sources: Winterborne Butt-Gantrell family: parish-register transcriptions
Sources: Winterborne Butt-Gantrell family: parish-register transcriptions; Winterborne Houghton parish-register transcription: Robert Butt baptized 17 September 1616; Dorset Online Parish Clerk: Winterborne Houghton parish records and archival holdings; Antony Broad research report, 29 July 2003: Winterborne Stickland Gantrell entries
Susan Gantrell was baptized on 18 August 1585 and married Robert Butt on 13 April 1607.
The underlying report labels the register section Winterborne Stickland, whereas the derivative family page gives the 1607 marriage as Winterborne Houghton. The reconstruction quotes these events. The 1616 baptism names only the child's father in the quoted wording, so Susan's maternity follows from the intact marriage and surrounding child sequence rather than from an explicitly named mother. 18 August 1585 is a baptism date, not a documented birth date. Original images are needed to settle locality labels.
record_context: status source_backed; confidence 0.86.
The transcription gives the family events. Dorset OPC describes surviving register coverage, but it does not itself publish the relevant sixteenth- and seventeenth-century entries.
reported_life_span: status reported; confidence 0.86.
This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates.
Child: Robert Butt of the Southern Branch — Reassessment 15 September 2026. H1: the Dorset Robert baptized in 1616 became the Virginia Robert deceased 1676. H2: he remained in Dorset and appears in later local records. H3: those later records concern other local Roberts. Broad’s report supplies an actual younger Robert, baptized 12 April 1647, son of Symon; if he survived, he would be about 31 in 1678, whereas the 1616 child would be about 62. The 1678 marriage to Grace Dennes gives no age, parent or residence, so it cannot distinguish these candidates. The 1647 child was about 17 in 1664 and is not automatically the three-hearth taxpayer either. The 1641 return could concern the older father or 1616 son; it predates the younger child. These events must not be combined into one continuous life without identity evidence. H1 has positive name and chronological compatibility; H2 no longer has the claimed substantial advantage from the 1678 marriage. Overall transatlantic identity remains unresolved. Kinship, occupation, property, local burial or migration evidence would discriminate. Ordinal tentative assessment revised; no calibrated probability or multiplied path probability is claimed. Susan’s maternity of the 1616 child is reconstructed from the 1607 marriage and child sequence, a separate inference from the Atlantic identity.
Parent candidate / recorded parent: Richard Gantrell — Explicit parent naming in the quoted 1585 baptism strongly supports Richard as Susan’s father within this Dorset household. His identity with the Richard buried in 1591 is a separate inference. The unresolved identification of Susan’s son with the Virginia Robert Butt does not reduce the local parent-child evidence. No end-to-end probability is inferred from this edge score.
Parent candidate / recorded parent: Aves — The quoted baptism explicitly names Aves as Richard Gantrell’s wife and Susan’s mother. Her maiden surname and parents remain unknown. This local relationship is strongly supported independently of the unresolved Dorset-to-Virginia identity; numerical edge judgments must not be multiplied into an ancestry probability.
Partner: Robert Butt of Winterborne — The published page quotes the parish wording. The original image has not yet been inspected, and the page's Houghton/Stickland locality labels should be checked against it.