Profile ID: C_BUTT_RICHARD_ELDER_1645. Status: researched_candidate.
same name generation context — A man explicitly styled Richard Butt junior helped prove John Godfrey's will — 15 May 1710–15 May 1710 — Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America
Sources: Charles Fleming McIntosh, Brief Abstract of Lower Norfolk County and Norfolk County Wills, 1637-1710
family and community associate — Richard Butt senior was named in the bond material for George Burgis and singlewoman Mary Butt — reported June 1711–reported June 1711 — Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America
disputed spouse assignment — The 13 June 1715 marriage of Richard Butt and Dina Butt more likely involved the younger Richard than Richard the Elder — 13 Jun 1715–13 Jun 1715 — Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America
Sources: Lower Norfolk County Virginia Antiquary, volume 3: abstracts of Norfolk County marriage bonds, 1711 and 1715; Charles Fleming McIntosh, Brief Abstract of Lower Norfolk County and Norfolk County Wills, 1637-1710; History of the Butt Family in Virginia and North Carolina
property and community role — A newly erected house on his land was selected as a dissenting place of worship — 17 Jan 1714–17 Jan 1714 — Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River, Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America
Sources: William H. Stewart, History of Norfolk County, Virginia: Richard Butt meetinghouse, 1714
documented household — Josias Mackie named Thomas, Elizabeth, and Henry as children of Mr Richard Butt — 7 Nov 1716–16 Nov 1716 — Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America
Sources: Isaac Marshall Page, The Life Story of Rev. Francis Makemie: transcript of Josias Mackie will, 1716
reported life span — This profile reports a birth reported about 1645 in reported Norfolk County, Virginia; a death reported 1727 in reported Norfolk County, Virginia. — reported about 1645–reported 1727 — reported Norfolk County, Virginia
Sources: FamilySearch collaborative profile: Robert Butt, about 1678-before 21 May 1731; Marshall Wingfield Butt, An Account of Some of the Descendants of Robert Butt of Southern Branch of Elizabeth River; History of the Butt Family in Virginia and North Carolina; Generation 12 terminal-branch expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Generation 13 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Generation-13 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026; Charles Fleming McIntosh, Brief Abstract of Lower Norfolk County and Norfolk County Wills, 1637-1710; Lower Norfolk County Virginia Antiquary, volume 3: abstracts of Norfolk County marriage bonds, 1711 and 1715; William H. Stewart, History of Norfolk County, Virginia: Richard Butt meetinghouse, 1714; Isaac Marshall Page, The Life Story of Rev. Francis Makemie: transcript of Josias Mackie will, 1716
local historical context — Probate and land evidence places the family among Norfolk County households organized around the Southern Branch of the Elizabeth River — 1670–1782 — Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America and United States
Sources: FamilySearch collaborative profile: Robert Butt, about 1678-before 21 May 1731; Marshall Wingfield Butt, An Account of Some of the Descendants of Robert Butt of Southern Branch of Elizabeth River; History of the Butt Family in Virginia and North Carolina; Generation 12 terminal-branch expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Generation 13 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Generation-13 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026; Chesapeake Public Schools local history: Robert Butt and the Southern Branch land
This tree includes proposed relationships as well as established ones. Link confidence scores are research assessments, not calibrated statistical probabilities. A person in the directory may be a research candidate rather than an ancestor. Family roots describe historical context, not additional biological parents.
Sources: FamilySearch collaborative profile: Robert Butt, about 1678-before 21 May 1731; History of the Butt Family in Virginia and North Carolina; Generation 12 terminal-branch expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Generation 13 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026
Sources: Marshall Wingfield Butt, An Account of Some of the Descendants of Robert Butt of Southern Branch of Elizabeth River; History of the Butt Family in Virginia and North Carolina; Generation 13 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026
Sources: Marshall Wingfield Butt, An Account of Some of the Descendants of Robert Butt of Southern Branch of Elizabeth River; Generation 13 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026
Sources: FamilySearch collaborative profile: Robert Butt, about 1678-before 21 May 1731; History of the Butt Family in Virginia and North Carolina; Generation 12 terminal-branch expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Generation 13 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026
Sources: FamilySearch collaborative profile: Robert Butt, about 1678-before 21 May 1731; Marshall Wingfield Butt, An Account of Some of the Descendants of Robert Butt of Southern Branch of Elizabeth River; History of the Butt Family in Virginia and North Carolina; Generation 12 terminal-branch expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Generation 13 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Generation-13 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026; Charles Fleming McIntosh, Brief Abstract of Lower Norfolk County and Norfolk County Wills, 1637-1710; Lower Norfolk County Virginia Antiquary, volume 3: abstracts of Norfolk County marriage bonds, 1711 and 1715; William H. Stewart, History of Norfolk County, Virginia: Richard Butt meetinghouse, 1714; Isaac Marshall Page, The Life Story of Rev. Francis Makemie: transcript of Josias Mackie will, 1716
A separate bond records Richard Butt and Dina Butt on 13 June 1715. Later accounts assigning Dinah and nine children to the elder appear to conflate generations. A court-record quotation says that a newly erected meetinghouse stood on his land in January 1714. Josias Mackie's 1716 will separately names Thomas, Elizabeth, and Henry as children of Mr Richard Butt and gives an item to Mr Richard Butt senior.
The 1675 will of Robert Butt names a son Richard, and later family history identifies that son as Richard Butt the Elder. The zero-source FamilySearch claim that Richard and Sarach Sayer parented Robert about 1678 is therefore retained only as a sharply downgraded possibility. Directly inspected county-record abstracts distinguish Richard Butt senior from Richard Butt junior: the junior helped prove John Godfrey's will on 15 May 1710, while a 1711 marriage bond names Richard Butt senior. Because a younger Richard was already explicitly present, the 1715 groom is more plausibly that younger man than the elder reportedly born about 1645. Additional Norfolk evidence places Richard Butt senior in the Southern Branch dissenting community. These records establish Richard's household and continued presence but do not name Robert born about 1678 as his son. However, the same history identifies Richard's wives as Dinah Butt and Frances and lists nine children without Robert.
property: status unverified; confidence 0.78.
property — A newly erected house on Richard Butt Sr.'s land was selected as a dissenting Protestant meetinghouse — 17 Jan 1714 — Southern Branch, Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America
Sources: William H. Stewart, History of Norfolk County, Virginia: Richard Butt meetinghouse, 1714
Name, senior styling, locality, and chronology fit this profile, but the record does not name a wife or son Robert.
occupation_status: status unresolved; confidence 0.99.
occupation status — No occupation has been established from the person-specific evidence currently cited
Sources: FamilySearch collaborative profile: Robert Butt, about 1678-before 21 May 1731; Marshall Wingfield Butt, An Account of Some of the Descendants of Robert Butt of Southern Branch of Elizabeth River; History of the Butt Family in Virginia and North Carolina; Generation 12 terminal-branch expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Generation 13 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Generation-13 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026
This records an evidence gap. It does not mean the person had no paid work, trade, farm work, household labor, or other productive role, and no occupation is inferred from a spouse, locality, surname, status, or descendant.
education_status: status unresolved; confidence 0.99.
education status — No education, apprenticeship, school attendance, academic status, or literacy result has been established
Sources: FamilySearch collaborative profile: Robert Butt, about 1678-before 21 May 1731; Marshall Wingfield Butt, An Account of Some of the Descendants of Robert Butt of Southern Branch of Elizabeth River; History of the Butt Family in Virginia and North Carolina; Generation 12 terminal-branch expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Generation 13 frontier expansion review, 24 Jul 2026; Generation-13 biographical enrichment review, 25 Jul 2026
This records an evidence gap, not an assertion that the person lacked education, literacy, informal learning, religious instruction, or occupational training.
local_historical_context: status source_based_context; confidence 0.98.
The shared locality does not prove that every person owned land, logged timber, enslaved people, held office, or shared the same household.
disputed_identity_alias: status disputed; confidence 0.05.
disputed identity alias — Some collaborative trees combine Richard Butt the Elder with the name Radford — reported Norfolk County, Virginia, British Colonial America
Sources: Frederick A. Virkus, The Abridged Compendium of American Genealogy, volume 1 (1925), pages 525 and 970; WikiTree profile Butt-441: Robert Butt of Lower Norfolk County; Ted Butts, 10 July 2000 online report of a family tree on the reverse of Sarah Bruce Butt's sampler
Robert's 1675 will names a son Richard. Virkus's 1925 pedigree instead names Radford as the son of a Robert and Ann Riddlehurst. The reported sampler-reverse pedigree names Richard, not Radford. The hybrid label Richard (Radford) should not be treated as a historical alias or used to join the two families.
same_name_generation_context: status source_backed; confidence 0.99.
This does not by itself state the junior man's father, but it proves that an older and younger same-name distinction was in use before the 1715 Dinah Butt marriage.
family_and_community_associate: status source_backed; confidence 0.98.
Thomas Butt was also named. The abstract proves association but does not label either man as Mary's father or brother.
disputed_spouse_assignment: status probable_generation_correction; confidence 0.85.
The marriage itself is secure. Assignment to the younger Richard is inferential but chronologically much stronger: the elder's reported circa-1645 birth would make him about seventy, incompatible with the later story that this was his first marriage followed by nine children before Dinah's reported 1726 death.
property_and_community_role: status source_backed; confidence 0.98.
The record shows that Richard owned land suitable for a meetinghouse and was associated with the local dissenting congregation. It does not identify his birthplace or wife.
documented_household: status source_backed; confidence 0.96.
The wording strongly associates these three children with the documented Richard senior, although it does not explicitly repeat “senior” in each child clause. The will also names several other Butt witnesses. It does not name Robert born about 1678 as Richard's child; that absence is informative but not proof that no such relationship existed.
reported_life_span: status reported; confidence 0.74.
This summary repeats existing reported vital fields; it does not independently verify the identity or the dates.
Child: Robert Butt — FamilySearch supplies this parent claim without records. The Virginia/North Carolina Butt family history lists nine children of Richard and does not include Robert. The link remains visible only as a low-probability alternative pending inspection of the underlying Norfolk probate material.
Parent candidate / recorded parent: Robert Butt of the Southern Branch — Robert's will directly names a son Richard. The identification with this Norfolk elder Richard is supported by locality, chronology, and the later family history, though no birth or uniquely identifying record was found.
Parent candidate / recorded parent: Jane Butt — Jane was Robert's wife when his 1675 will named son Richard. She is chronologically and contextually the likely mother, but maternity is inferential and her maiden name is unknown.
Partner: Sarach (possibly Sarah) Sayer — No record independently identifies Sarach or Sarah Sayer as this Richard's wife. The formerly cited alternative placing Dinah Butt with the elder is also unreliable: county abstracts distinguish a Richard junior by 1710, making the younger man the more plausible groom in the 1715 Richard-and-Dina bond.